Two decades of Utopia

Utopia Deli celebrates great eats, good friends and more to come

Make text smaller Make text larger


  • Flashback to Feb. 11, 1997. That was when Susan Costanza, left, and Donald Dickerson, right, opened their deli and cafe, Utopia, on Warwick Turnpike in Hewitt.

  • Utopia Deli and Cafe is celebrating 20 years! Pictured here, from left, are Manager Ruth Russo, co-owner Susan Costanza, MindyWasyluk and co-owner Donald Dickerson.


Sue Costanza and her brothers all learned to cook from their mom, Mary Rennell, and turned that love of cooking for others into businesses.

Costanza and her husband, Donald Dickert, own Utopia Deli and Cafe and the adjacent Suzy's Tomato Pizzeria in Hewitt. This Feb. 11 marks their 20th anniversary in business here.

Cooking is a family affairUtopia Deli offers everything you could wish for in a deli and more: great hot meals and sandwiches, homemade soups and salads and fresh baked muffins, brownies and cookies in a clean, friendly atmosphere.

When Costanza was younger, her family owned the Marketplace Deli. Her brother Phil still operates the Marketplace in Highland Lakes, while her brother Mark, who owned The Huntsman, retired. Costanza says she learned from them, as well.

Costanza said she's proud to be in business for 20 years. Owning your own business can be difficult and time-consuming.

Except for one other business, she said "All the surrounding places have changed hands a number of times."

It can be a lot of work finding and keeping good help. "That's what it takes," she said.

Good peopleCostanza has valued full-time employees who have been with her for years and who have become friends: manager Ruth Russo and Mindy Wasyluk. In addition, the business hires part-time help as needed.

"The job's not easy; they have a lot of stuff to learn, but when they (leave) they're very capable."

Costanza had high praise for the young people who have worked for her.

"I've had the best kids because the majority of them are very responsible," she said. "They show up when they're supposed to and find coverage when they can't come in. They're experienced dealing with people, handling situations and preparing food."

Many of them are college bound, she added. Some get married and Costanza and Dickert have gone to their weddings. “They became our kids."

She values her people, for sure.

"I've been very fortunate, as far as I'm concerned. I've had some of the best people working for me," she said.

A work of loveCostanza and Dickert live in Hewitt. Costanza was born in Hoboken and moved here when she was four. Dickert has lived here his entire life.

Dickert was into refurbishing homes when he and Sue met. The couple knew they wanted to bring something new to the area and decided to open a deli. A friend, Glen Slater, was refurbishing the building they're in now and the couple decided to rent and refinish the space for the deli. Dickert did everything himself, Costanza said: he made the kitchen, counters, and installed the floors.

"He didn't come from that but he is able to figure things out and not afraid to try and succeed at it," she said.

It took them three years to complete; both were busy with other things, but then they opened the Utopia Deli.

How did they hit on the name "Utopia?" Costanza said it was because of the beauty of the area.

High praiseNot only can you eat in or take out food, but the Utopia caters as well. Some customer favorites include their heroes, the cold Sloppy Joe, the Utopia salad and a whole array of wraps. Customers come for the atmosphere as well as the food. "We have seating outside too," Costanza said, "with a nice pond."

Customers have high praise for Utopia Deli and the staff.

“The early morning opening crew are always bright eyed and ready to break some eggs,” posted customer Harry Clark on facebook. “Pouring that hot coffee with a smile and a brisk 'have a great day'!! Great place!”

“To all of our customers, thank you for your loyalty for the past 20 years and for being part of our family,” said Costanza.

Check them out on facebook, where you can see the daily specials, too.

"I've been very fortunate, as far as I'm concerned. I've had some of the best people working for me."
Sue Costanza, co-owner of Utopia Deli and Cafe, which is celebrating its 20th anniversary on Feb. 11, 2017

Utopia Deli
355 Warwick Turnpike
Open every day, 5 a.m. to 9:30 p.m.

Make text smaller Make text larger


Pool Rules


Edward S. Bachorik
Edward S. Bachorik of Highland Mills passed away Thursday, Jan. 11, at Orange Regional Medical Center in the Town of Wallkill, NY. He was 82. The son of Stephen P. Bachorik and...
Read more »

Where in West Milford?
Where in West Milford have you seen this detail? If you think you know, fill out the form below.
Read more »

Where in responses
Uncorked Wines and Spirits on Marshall Hill Road not only has a friendly staff to help customers pick out the perfect bottle for any occasion, it also has bar where it sells vino...
Read more »

State rescinds school district's notice of 'poor internal controls'
By Patricia Keller
West Milford school officials say they have resolved a situation that could have affected the...

Read more »


* indicates required
Community Newspapers


Where in answers
Where in responses
  • Jan 11, 2018
Edward S. Bachorik
  • Jan 12, 2018
Where in clues
Where in West Milford?
  • Jan 11, 2018


West Milford, NJ